PhotoShelter Stories
  • Learn About PhotoShelter
  • DAM 101
  • PhotoShelter Brands News
  • Real-Time Workflow
  • Behind the Scenes with the Storytellers
Stories by PhotoShelter for Brands
  • Features
    • Behind the Scenes
      • Binge Watch
    • Real-Time Workflow
    • DAM 101
    • Trendsetters
    • Content Strategy
    • PhotoShelter News
  • Industries
    • Professional Sports
    • College Sports
    • Education
    • Nonprofit
    • Hospitals & Healthcare
    • Food & Beverage
    • Government
    • Consumer Goods
    • Corporate
    • Retail
    • Travel & Tourism
  • Learn
    • Join Slack Community
    • Summit Sessions
    • Guides
    • Webinars
    • Case Studies
    • Product Updates
    • Meet PhotoShelter
  • PhotoShelter Brands
    • Home
    • Get PhotoShelter
    • Subscribe
  • DAM 101

Copyright Infringement Cases Every Brand Should Know

  • 3 minute read
  • 4.9K views
  • Allen Murabayashi

With few exceptions, copyright infringement lawsuits rarely generate headlines. This might lead brands to believe that the incidence of infringements and actions by the copyright holder are low, but this is an erroneous assumption.

According to attorney Edward Greenberg, “99% [of copyright infringement cases] are handled on a confidential basis…” Most cases are settled out of court, and even the ones that get a court date are largely settled before going to a jury because it can be incredibly expensive to litigate.

Even if your company is dead set on using free content (here’s why that’s a bad idea), you still have a legal and fiduciary responsibility to ensure that the way you use content has an appropriate license and, where necessary (as in the case of some Creative Commons licenses), proper attribution.

Check out the copyright infringement cases below to get a better understanding of the consequences, and to ensure your team isn’t making the same mistakes.

Andrew Paul Leonard v Stemtech Health Sciences, Inc

Plaintiff attorney: Seitz, Van Ogtrop & Green, P.A.

Key concept: Copyright infringement and registration

Details: Microphotography expert Andrew Paul Leonard’s photographs of bone marrow stem cells were stolen and used on the Stemtech website and other marketing materials.

Status: The court ruled in Leonard’s favor for copyright infringement, awarding him $1.6m in actual damages. However, he was denied statutory damages because he didn’t register his images until after the infringement occurred.

Reinsdorf v Skechers

Plaintiff attorney: JML Law

Key concept: Copyright infringement and registration

Details: Photographer Richard Reinsdorf sued Skechers for using his images in certain advertisements beyond the previously agreed license. Reinsdorf claimed damages as a percentage of Skechers’ total revenues, amounting to $250m. Skechers claimed that they were co-authors of the images because they retouched the final images.

Status: The court ruled that Skechers’ claims of co-authorship were dubious, but couldn’t find a causal relationship between the infringement and revenue. Additionally, Reinsdorf failed to register his images prior to the alleged infringement, and thus was denied statutory damages.

McGann v Bruno Mars

Plaintiff attorney: Liebowitz Law Firm, PLLC

Key concept: Copyright infringement, social media use, and DMCA

Details: Photographer Catherine McGann posted her photo of a young Bruno Mars in Elvis regalia to her Instagram. In turn, Peter Gene Hernandez (aka Bruno Mars) posted the photo with her copyright watermark removed – a violation of the Digital Millenium Copyright Act – on his Instagram account. 

Status: Dismissal with prejudice (The case was likely settled)

Michael Miller v Kendall Jenner

Plaintiff attorney: Doniger / Burroughs

Key concept: Copyright infringement

Details: As a part of a limited edition series under the Kendall + Kylie capsule collection, Michael Miller’s image of Tupac Shakur was stolen and printed on t-shirts alongside other deceased musicians including Notorious B.I.G. and Jim Morrison. The shirts were quickly pulled and Jenner apologized, but Miller filed suit for the blatant infringement.

Status: Settled through mediation

Dancel v Groupon

Plaintiff attorney: Edelson PC

Key concept: Rights of publicity

Details: Groupon used Instagram’s API to scrape photo from user accounts without their permission. The location tagged images featuring identifiable people were then used by Groupon to advertise deals with various businesses – violating Indiana state law to control how one’s likeness is used for commercial purposes. Dancel is the lead plaintiff in a class action suit that was filed in 2016, and still unresolved. In other words, irrespective of outcome, both parties have undoubtedly racked up major legal bills.

Status: On-going

Disclaimer: This article does not constitute legal advice. Always consult with a lawyer.


Copyright Crash Course: What Marketers Need to Know

Want to learn more about copyright? Watch our on-demand webinar, Copyright Crash Course: What Marketers Need to Know!

In this on-demand webinar, you’ll learn:

  • What an image license is in relation to your brand’s content
  • The dangers of using free content
  • How to navigate copyright in the age of social media
  • Lessons from copyright battles between brands and creators
  • Tips for managing usage rights and a new solution from PhotoShelter that will help you navigate these complicated issues

 
Next Up: A Picture Is Worth a Thousand Words – and Maybe a Million-Dollar Lawsuit

Tweet
Share
Share
Allen Murabayashi

Related Topics
  • brand
  • copyright
  • image rights
  • photography
  • photos
  • public relations
  • tips
  • usage rights
  • visual assets
  • visual content
Previous Article
Copyright for Marketers: All Your Questions Answered, Photo by Allen Murabayashi
  • DAM 101

Copyright for Marketers: All Your Questions Answered

  • Kristin Twiford
View Post
Next Article
Behind the Scenes: Video Workflow, Tips and Ideas to Steal
  • Content Strategy

Behind the Scenes: Content Marketing Video Workflow, Tips and Ideas to Steal

  • Kristin Twiford
View Post
You May Also Like
View Post
  • Content Strategy
  • Real-Time Workflow
  • Trendsetters

Game Day Workflows: Get the Most Out of Your Major League Moments

  • John Seibels
View Post
  • Content Strategy
  • Real-Time Workflow

[Watch] Tapping Into Your Advocates for Brand Storytelling

  • John Seibels
View Post
  • Content Strategy
  • DAM 101
  • Real-Time Workflow

[WATCH] Behind the Lens with Ron Vesely

  • Jeremy Berkowitz
Voice in Shape's Depiction of the 2021 Vision: Workflow Summit Opening Moments
View Post
  • Content Strategy
  • Real-Time Workflow
  • Trendsetters

How to Push the Boundary of Your Virtual Event

  • Rachel Brown
View Post
  • Behind the Scenes with the Storytellers
  • Content Strategy

Influencer Storytelling With the LPGA and PGA Tour

  • John Seibels
View Post
  • DAM 101
  • Trendsetters

How Workflows Are Changing for Creative Professionals

  • Jeremy Berkowitz
View Post
  • Content Strategy
  • Real-Time Workflow

6 Things I Wish I Knew Before Hosting A Virtual Event

  • Rachel Brown
View Post
  • Content Strategy
  • Real-Time Workflow

Our Team’s Playbook: PhotoShelter’s Ultimate Virtual Events Checklist

  • Yoav B. Guttman
12 comments
  1. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know - News Diary
  2. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know via @annaleacrowe - Silicon Boardwalk
  3. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know – Seo News Portal
  4. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know via @annaleacrowe - #KickassDigital
  5. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know via @annaleacrowe - WP Epitome
  6. Pingback: 您需要了解的11个重要图像SEO提示 – WP建站
  7. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know via @annaleacrowe - the Digital Ninja Club
  8. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know via @annaleacrowe | Website Pro USA
  9. Pingback: 11 Image Optimization SEO Tips 2020 You Need to Know (Important) - FunnyWill
  10. Pingback: 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know – Ankit Jha | Juvenile Writer
  11. Pingback: SEO 11 Important Image SEO Tips You Need to Know via @annaleacrowe – My Demo Blog
  12. Pingback: Maximize Your Findability and Speed using Image SEO | SEO Secret Sauce | Las Vegas Google Ranking Services

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe
Categories
  • Behind the Scenes with the Storytellers
  • Real-Time Workflow
  • DAM 101
  • Trendsetters
  • Content Strategy
  • PhotoShelter News
Social Links
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
LinkedIn
Recent Posts
  • Game Day Workflows: Get the Most Out of Your Major League Moments
  • [Watch] Tapping Into Your Advocates for Brand Storytelling
  • [WATCH] Behind the Lens with Ron Vesely
  • How to Push the Boundary of Your Virtual Event
  • Influencer Storytelling With the LPGA and PGA Tour
Featured Posts
  • open_demo_puple_background.jpg
    [Open Demo] What’s New with PhotoShelter for Brands with Travis Roberts on 10/29
    • 1 minute read
    • 49 views
  • All Your Questions Answered: AI, WordPress, Workspaces and More
    • 4 minute read
    • 641 views
  • 20/21 Vision: The Strategy Summit is Now On-Demand
    • 1 minute read
    • 15 views
  • Recreational Boating & Fishing Foundation’s AI-Powered Content Strategy
    • 3 minute read
    • 726 views
Stories by PhotoShelter for Brands
Transforming the way creative people work.

Input your search keywords and press Enter.